Tracker Autumn 2001

NEWS & COMMENTARY
An Outlook on Occupational Medicine Events
News & Commentary

U.S. HealthWorks Completes Acquisition of HealthSouth’s Occupational Medicine Clinics

New England Journal of Medicine Releases Three Lyme Disease Studies Early

CDC Issues Report on TB

Startling Statistics on Provision of Preventive Healthcare Services in America

Employers Increase Prevention & Cost Containment Offerings


U.S. HealthWorks Completes Acquisition of HealthSouth’s Occupational Medicine Clinics

On April 25th U.S. HealthWorks announced it had completed the acquisition of HealthSouth’s Occupational Medicine Division.

With the acquisition, U.S. HealthWorks more than doubles in size. It now has 162 locations in 29 states, making it the second largest for-profit occupational medicine clinic chain; Concentra has 216 centers in 65 markets in 32 states.

"This transaction is a transcending event for U.S. HealthWorks," said Richard J. Kampa, chairman of the board and chief executive officer. "With the investment capital and successful completion of this major acquisition, we have solidified our position as the emerging leader in the occupational health industry. The addition of the acquired health centers strengthens our presence in existing markets and provides geographic expansion in other targeted markets. These centers will also improve the company’s ability to serve multi-site employers and improve ease of access and convenience for our employers and patients."

Richard M. Scrushy, chairman of the board and chief executive officer of HealthSouth, said, "This transaction will enable HealthSouth to focus even more resources on our core lines of businesses…."

[Comment: In the Autumn 1999 issue of the Tracker, I wrote about the collapse of occupational medicine clinic stocks. That article discussed how Concentra and Novacare responded to the stock price collapse by being purchased privately. HealthSouth was the third stock discussed, and now it has also sold its clinics privately. Those of you who have been watching will note that HealthSouth’s stock price has recovered significantly from its lows from last year. This sale represents consolidation in the for-profit occupational medicine clinic business and core-business focusing for HealthSouth. – William L. Newkirk (wln), MD, FACPM]

New England Journal of Medicine Releases Three Lyme Disease Studies Early

On June 12th the New England Journal of Medicine released early three studies scheduled for publication on July 12, because of their potential importance in the treatment of Lyme Disease.

In the first study, Robert Nadelman, MD and colleagues conducted a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial of treatment with a single 200 mg dose of doxycycline in 482 subjects who had removed attached I. scapularis ticks from their bodies within the previous 72 hours.

The study concluded that a single 200 mg dose of doxycycline given within 72 hours after an I. scapularis tick bite can prevent the development of Lyme disease.

The second paper by Mark S. Klempner, MD and colleagues examined patients with well-documented, previously treated Lyme Disease who had persistent musculoskeletal pain, neurocognitive symptoms, or dysesthesia, often associated with fatigue. The paper describes two randomized trials: one in 78 patients who were seropositive for IgG antibodies to Borrelia burgdorferi at the time of enrollment and the other in 51 patients who were seronegative.

The studies conclude that "there is considerable impairment of health-related quality of life among patients with persistent symptoms despite previous antibiotic treatment for acute Lyme Disease. However, in these two trials, treatment with intravenous and oral antibiotics for 90 days did not improve symptoms more than placebo."

In 1999, the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) received reports of 16,019 cases of Lyme Disease. Ninety-two percent of those cases were in nine states, mostly in the northeastern United States.

[Comment: These studies affect occupational medicine clinics in two ways. First, patients who previously have had Lyme Disease do present with a variety of vague symptoms, including muscle pain and mental impairment. The practitioner is often asked whether this represents persisting Lyme Disease or whether it is another problem (fibromyalgia, solvent exposure, etc.). And how should it be treated? It is a puzzle with no solution—yet. These studies demonstrate that one antibiotic regimen that might be expected to treat chronic Borrelia burgdorferi infection convincingly doesn’t work. Could other antibiotic regimens work? No one knows for certain. But, after these studies, physicians advocating such an approach had better develop a more substantiated scientific basis than they have at present.

Second, what do you do for a worker who has been bitten by a tick capable of causing Lyme Disease in a Lyme endemic area? Eugene D. Shapiro, MD, writing an editorial in NEJM, answers: "Who should receive doxycycline for a tick bite? It may be reasonable to administer doxycycline to persons bitten by ticks in areas where the incidence of Lyme Disease is high and when the tick is a nymphal deer tick that is at least partially engorged with blood.

"In the far more common circumstances in which the bite occurs in an area where the incidence of Lyme Disease is not high, in which the tick is not a nymphal deer tick (or either the species or the stage of the tick is unknown), or in which the tick is not at least partially engorged, the risk of Lyme Disease is likely to be so low that prophylaxis with doxycycline is not indicated. Persons who have received Lyme Disease vaccine should also be at lower risk. The potential risks and benefits of prophylaxis should be discussed with the patient, who should be involved in making the decision. If chemoprophylaxis is chosen, only a single dose of doxycycline should be administered—with food, to minimize nausea.

"Whatever course is chosen, patients should be instructed to seek treatment if an expanding erythematous rash develops at the site of the bite. In addition, they should be reassured that the prognosis is excellent for the small minority of patients in whom Lyme Disease does develop after a tick bite."

I suspect that when the information from this study become public, a high percentage of people receiving bites will want prophylaxis. Wouldn’t you? – wln]

[top]

CDC Issues Report on TB

On June 12th the CDC released its latest report on the number of new cases of tuberculosis in the U.S., which indicated that TB declined by 7% from 1999 to 2000, continuing an eight year decline since the TB epidemic peaked in 1992. The ten states with the highest TB rates were (in ranking order) Alaska, Hawaii, California, New York, Georgia, Arkansas, Louisiana, Florida, Texas, and South Carolina. More information or copies of the report are available from the CDC at www.cdc.gov or 404.639.8896.

Startling Statistics on Provision of Preventive Healthcare Services in America

Fewer than half the American population receives some of the most valuable healthcare services. In a study, jointly sponsored by the CDC and Partnership for Prevention, 30 preventive health services were prioritized based on the services’ health benefits and cost-effectiveness. Several services ranked high on the list, yet currently reach less than half the Americans: tobacco cessation counseling, screening older adults for undetected vision impairments, screening adults 50+ for colorectal cancer, screening young women for chlamydia, screening and counseling adults for problem drinking, and vaccinating older adults against pneumococcal disease.

"The study will help decision makers in the healthcare industry prioritize the preventive services that not only save the most lives, but also the most money in the long run," said CDC Director Jeffrey Koplan, MD, MPH. "These gaps in care should be closed for the benefit of everyone." Two articles about the study appeared in the July 2001 issue of the American Journal of Preventive Medicine (AJPM). More information is available at the web sites of the two sponsoring organizations: www.cdc.gov or www.elsevier.com (for AJPM).

Employers Increase Prevention & Cost Containment Offerings

Despite double-digit healthcare cost increases and a slowing economy, more employers are offering health promotion and management programs, according to a new survey from Hewitt Associates. Some type of education or training program is in place at 71% of the companies surveyed, up 5% from 1995. Corporate financial incentive and disincentive programs, such as gifts or monetary awards for employee health appraisal participation, or higher insurance premiums for smokers, are on the rise, at 40% now compared with 32% in 1995. Increasingly, employers are looking for creative and effective solutions, such as health promotion and medical management programs that can provide cost savings, reduce absenteeism, and increase productivity. For more, go to www.hewitt.com.

[top]


Tracker Autumn 2001 Main Page
Home | Contact Information | Search | E-mail Us